Alleged preppy killer Matthew Hertgen appeared in a New Jersey courtroom for his first in-person hearing, facing charges for the bashing and slashing death of his younger brother Joseph. Hertgen’s wealthy parents, David and Debra, did not attend the court proceedings. Despite the family’s wealth, Hertgen agreed to be held in jail until his trial on murder and animal cruelty charges, as he was represented by a public defender. His older brother gave an emotional eulogy at Joseph’s funeral, describing him as a beloved family member.
During the court appearance, Hertgen acknowledged his constitutional rights and agreed to remain in custody. The public defender assigned to his case stated that there were no plans for the family to hire a private defense attorney, even though Hertgen’s father holds a high-ranking position at a tech company. Hertgen has the option to file an appeal within seven days if he wishes to change his mind about staying in jail before his trial. The next court appearance was scheduled for March 24, and Hertgen had previously attempted to hang himself in jail.
The alleged killer is facing 30 years to life in prison if convicted for the murder of his brother. Months before the gruesome crime, Hertgen posted disturbing poems on Facebook that alluded to violence and bloodshed. He also took a selfie with a cat toy a day before the murder. The Hertgen brothers were both former college soccer players and grew up in an affluent household before the family moved to a luxurious location in Princeton. The murder occurred in the family’s upscale apartment, where units can cost up to $2 million.
Police discovered the crime scene after Hertgen called to report a dead body and a fire in the family home. A knife, fork, and plate covered in blood were found near the victim’s body, leading authorities to suspect that Hertgen may have consumed his brother’s missing eye. The motive for the horrific crime has not been revealed, leaving many who knew the family shocked and confused. Hertgen’s twisted actions have left the community reeling as they try to make sense of the tragedy. Despite his family’s wealth and privilege, Hertgen’s alleged violent behavior has resulted in a shocking and incomprehensible loss.
