New York City’s nightlife is constantly evolving, showcasing its eccentricity through a collection of unique bars that embrace the bizarre and the quirky. Five standout establishments exemplify this trend, ranging from a horror-themed spot with intriguing decor to a nautical-inspired bar that honors literary classics. Each location not only delivers captivating aesthetics but also offers inventive drinks and comfort food that cater to diverse tastes, contributing to the rich tapestry of the city’s nightlife.
The Flying Fox Tavern in Ridgewood stands out as a whimsical homage to horror culture, adorned with gothic chandeliers and spooky memorabilia that immerse guests in a delightfully eerie atmosphere. Since its inception in 2022, co-owner Tracy Bradbury and chef Chad Johnson have crafted a space for horror aficionados to indulge in delicious food and cocktails. Guests enter through a neon bat sign and can enjoy their meals at coffin-shaped picnic tables. The menu features surprising items like vegan stuffed French toast and Patrón-based drinks, making each visit both thrilling and delicious. The unique cocktail offerings, including the “Christopher Lee” margarita, not only celebrate horror films but also prompt lively discussions among patrons, enhancing the communal experience.
Quick Eternity, located at 22 Peck Slip, transports guests to a seafaring world inspired by Herman Melville’s “Moby-Dick.” Opened in May, this bar captures the essence of an old tavern with cocktails named after literary quotes and an inviting ambiance complete with vintage touches. Owner Bryan Schneider has collaborated with local artists and a bookseller to create an atmosphere that pays tribute to classic literature and maritime adventure. Quick Eternity features a menu filled with delicacies like crab fritters and lobster pups, accompanied by drinks like the namesake “Quick Eternity” cocktail, providing a delightful pre-dinner experience or a refreshing after-work retreat.
Miss Nellie’s brings a theatrical flair to Hell’s Kitchen, celebrating the legacy of investigative journalist Nellie Bly. This bar, which opened in October 2024, weaves a narrative into every aspect, from the decor to the creatively crafted cocktails. General manager Marisa Braat describes the venue as a cozy escape where visitors feel as if they’ve stumbled upon a hidden gem. Signature cocktails like suitcase-shaken martinis and whimsical takes on comfort food, such as smoked chicken bites, elevate the dining experience. Miss Nellie’s not only honors bold femininity and adventurous spirit but also promotes an interactive atmosphere where each drink comes with its own compelling story.
Turtles All the Way Down in Bed-Stuy takes a quirky approach by hosting monthly turtle races that have transformed it into a local favorite. The bar, dimly lit and known for its relaxed vibe, features beloved turtles, Ja Rule and Vita, who compete in playful races that attract crowds on the first Sunday of each month. This unusual event stems from a desire to create a unique experience for patrons, which has since grown in popularity, highlighted by social media buzz. Between races, guests can enjoy an array of casual bites and promotions, creating a lively setting that blends fun and community engagement.
Sailor’s Choice is a nautical-themed bar nestled near Hudson Yards, where visitors can unwind in a sun-soaked environment featuring a vintage fishing boat turned bar. Owned by brothers Miles and Alex Pincus, this establishment encapsulates a blend of gentleman’s yacht and rustic charm, with a menu boasting coastal favorites like lobster BLTs and crispy fish and chips. The outdoor layout, complete with lemon-striped umbrellas, serves as a vibrant backdrop for casual cocktails and social gatherings. With its laid-back atmosphere and delightful food offerings, Sailor’s Choice exemplifies a relaxed spot perfect for enjoying a sunny day or a tranquil evening by the water.
In a city where creativity knows no bounds, these five bars illustrate how New York City’s nightlife is thriving amidst eccentric concepts and captivating themes. From horror-themed watering holes and literary-inspired havens to quirky turtle race venues and nautical escapes, each of these locations not only defies traditional expectations but also fosters community and enriches the city’s vibrant bar scene. Through imaginative decor, inventive cocktails, and delicious food, these establishments embody the spirit of New York, making a compelling case that adventure and personality are always on tap.
