America’s most expensive broadband investment program, the Broadband Equity, Access and Deployment program (BEAD), recently lost its leader, Evan Feinman, who issued a warning about potential changes favoring Elon Musk’s Starlink satellite internet service. Feinman’s departure comes as the Department of Commerce, under Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick, plans to take a more “technology-neutral” approach to BEAD, potentially benefiting Starlink with additional funding. This shift from a fiber-first approach to one that favors satellite internet could have negative consequences for rural Americans in terms of education, economic outcomes, and health outcomes.
Feinman expressed his concern about the potential impact of prioritizing satellite internet over fiber in rural areas, citing issues related to speed and price. While Starlink’s service has gained popularity in rural areas with limited options, questions remain about its ability to meet BEAD’s speed requirements and provide a sustainable solution for future connectivity needs. Critics argue that Starlink’s speeds have decreased as more customers have joined the network, raising doubts about its scalability and long-term viability.
The BEAD program, which was established as part of the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act of 2021, aims to provide funding to improve broadband access in underserved communities. However, the recent shift towards a technology-neutral approach could potentially benefit companies like Starlink at the expense of traditional fiber-based providers. Critics argue that investing in expensive and potentially inadequate technology like satellite internet could be a waste of resources and hinder long-term connectivity goals.
The debate over the future of BEAD reflects broader discussions about the best approach to expanding broadband access in rural America. While satellite internet may offer a quick solution in areas with limited options, concerns remain about its long-term effectiveness and ability to meet evolving connectivity needs. As decisions about the program’s direction continue to evolve, stakeholders are encouraged to engage with elected officials and advocate for policies that prioritize sustainable and efficient broadband solutions that benefit all communities.
Evan Feinman’s departure from the BEAD program highlights the ongoing challenges and complexities of expanding broadband access in underserved communities. As the Department of Commerce considers changes to the program that could favor satellite internet providers like Starlink, concerns have been raised about the potential impact on rural Americans and the sustainability of these investments in the long run. Stakeholders are encouraged to engage with policymakers and advocate for solutions that prioritize reliable, high-speed internet access for all communities, while ensuring that taxpayer funds are allocated effectively and efficiently.
