In the fifth episode of The Deep End, Jon Nelson discusses depression as a misunderstood “no-casserole disease” with stigma around mental health. This episode explores the experience of suffering from depression and the harmful consequences of societal misconceptions about the disorder. Philosophical questions arise regarding the origins of self and the role of the brain in shaping one’s identity.
Emily Hollenbeck shares her encounters with people who don’t understand her mental illness, highlighting a lack of empathy in healthcare settings. The judgment and shame associated with seeking treatment for mental health issues are explored through personal anecdotes, illustrating how these attitudes can perpetuate silence and prevent individuals from seeking help. Jon Nelson’s analogy of receiving a casserole for cancer but not depression emphasizes the unequal treatment of mental health disorders.
The portrayal of mental illness often leads to misconceptions about treatment options, such as electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) or deep brain stimulation (DBS). Emily recounts facing criticism for her medical decisions and the misunderstandings surrounding ECT. Patient 001’s experience with DBS raises questions about the societal stigma attached to various treatments for mental disorders, including antidepressants, ECT, and DBS.
The fear of changing the brain through treatments like DBS brings about discomfort and uncertainty among patients and society. Concerns about altering one’s core identity and personality through brain interventions reflect broader societal reservations about mental health treatments. Jon and Amanda emphasize that DBS does not change their personality but alleviates symptoms, allowing them to reclaim their sense of self.
The impact of DBS on Jon’s life is evident in his improved mental health and daily functioning, despite lingering irritability. Loved ones like Barbara confirm Jon’s authenticity and continued identity, dispelling myths about brain implants altering a person’s essence. DBS is described as a tool for alleviating the effects of depression, rather than a transformative technology creating a new individual.
The final episode explores the future for Jon and DBS, reflecting on the unexpected journey and collective commitment to progress in mental health treatment. The series seeks to address audience questions and feedback, sparking conversations and insights into the complex nature of mental health disorders and innovative treatments like DBS. The Deep End confronts societal biases and stigma surrounding mental health, advocating for empathy, understanding, and support for those struggling with depression and other mental illnesses.
