New York Yankees ace Gerrit Cole is dealing with elbow soreness in his pitching elbow, which has raised concerns about the possibility of Tommy John surgery. General manager Brian Cashman admitted to preparing for the worst as they awaited the results of Cole’s MRI. Former MLB general manager Jim Bowden reported that Cole has been recommended to have Tommy John surgery, but they are waiting for a second opinion to confirm the diagnosis. If Cole undergoes this surgery, he would be sidelined for the entire 2025 season and potentially into 2026, leaving the Yankees scrambling to find a replacement.
The Yankees are already without Luis Gil, so they would need to find a replacement for Cole quickly. This injury could potentially lead to top prospect Will Warren being thrust into the rotation earlier than expected. Some trade options the Yankees could pursue to replace Cole include Erick Fedde, Dylan Cease, Sandy Alcántara, Sonny Gray, or Michael King. Regardless of who they choose, the Yankees need to act fast to ensure they have a suitable replacement for their injured ace as it seems unlikely that Cole will be able to pitch in 2025.
Gerrit Cole’s injury has created a challenging situation for the Yankees, who are now faced with the possibility of losing their ace for an extended period. Tommy John surgery would be a significant setback for the team, as they would need to find a way to replace his production on the mound. The second opinion on Cole’s condition could potentially change the course of action, but the situation has already taken a turn for the worse. The Yankees will need to act swiftly to address the void left by Cole’s potential absence for the upcoming season.
The loss of Gerrit Cole would be a significant blow to the Yankees, as he is a key player in their rotation. His absence would create a void that would need to be filled by either promoting a prospect or making a trade for an experienced starter. The team will need to evaluate their options carefully and make decisions quickly to ensure they are competitive for the upcoming season. Losing a player of Cole’s caliber is never easy, but the Yankees will need to adapt and find a way to move forward without him if his injury requires surgery.
The uncertainty surrounding Gerrit Cole’s injury has put the Yankees in a challenging position as they face the possibility of losing their ace for an extended period. The team will need to consider their available options and make decisions quickly to address the potential loss of Cole for the upcoming season. The second opinion on his condition will be crucial in determining the next steps for the team, but they must be prepared to move forward without him if surgery is required. The Yankees will need to act swiftly and decisively to ensure they have a plan in place to address the absence of Cole in their rotation.
